Thursday, 14 March 2013
UD: in praise of white space and bigger font
My daughter has recently started to enjoy chapter books. I have
noticed that even though she is a strong reader, she will make instant judgment
calls about which books are 'too hard' and which ones are 'just right' when we
go to the library. Books with text that is 'too small' she often
quickly dismisses, even though she is fully capable of understanding the text.
Watching Tatum choose her reading material makes me think about the students we
teach. How often do our students have a hard time 'buying in' when we offer text
that is at an appropriate reading level, but not designed in a reader-friendly
way?
'Universal Design' is a design concept that has
recently been adopted by educational professionals. 'Universal'
meaning design that benefits everyone- not just
individuals with particular needs. The basic principles of UD (The Center for
Universal Design) demand that design is simple and
intuitive, that information is perceptible and
that little physical effort is required for access.
Here are a couple of simple UD concepts that can make a big
difference for all your students (including English language learners):
White space is the space between letters, words, paragraphs,
columns, headings and graphics. It is an essential part of every page that you
hand out to your students. If a page has not enough white space, it becomes
crowded and may overwhelm the reader. It is hard to differentiate what is
important from what is not really that important. A cluttered page offers
nowhere for the student to jot personal responses to the text. It tires the
eyes.
Font size, that is. 12 point font is required by MLA, APA and the
University of Chicago writing standards. We demand this of our students when
they produce essays and research projects. Smaller font is more tiresome to read
and can give an impression to the reader that the content is more complex than
it actually is.
Headings and subheadings also enhance comprehension. Bold face
highlights key words. When our eyes see something on a page that is larger, our
brain naturally gets the message that it is more important. Note: many designers
also suggest using a contrasting font for headings and subheadings.
Please take two seconds to view the attached file below:
Article sample- UD-friendly version.
There, you will find a sample of an article that has been copied directly from the Winnipeg Free Press (online version).
Article sample- UD-friendly version.
There, you will find a sample of an article that has been copied directly from the Winnipeg Free Press (online version).
The original is in 9 point font, single spaced.
The second is the same article, however the font is 12 point and
the line space between words is 1.5 spaces. Breaks were added between
paragraphs. A few key concepts were bold faced. A few subheadings were
inserted to draw attention to main ideas. These changes took no longer than 5
minutes of my time, however the adapted text is less intimidating, easier to
navigate and friendlier to all.
One minute strategies-zero prep
1 minute strategies to adapt for EAL learners that take zero prep time
This
semester I am teaching a grade 11 chemistry class. There is an EAL student in my
class whose language skills are fairly low. I’ll call him Y. There are several
very quick strategies that I have used specifically with him in the last two
weeks to support his learning. There are also some things I do during
whole-class instruction to make things easier for him and to support the
learning of all students in my class.
I hope
you will find these quick and easy tips helpful, and I encourage you to choose a
couple that you will try out in your classroom.
Quick
strategies I use specifically with the EAL student in my class:
-When
I circulate as students are working each day, I always stop and ask Y a
specific question about the lesson to check for his understanding. Please
make a point of talking to the EAL students in your class and asking them
questions. They are often too shy to ask for help or tell you they don’t
understand something.
-When
I give a notes handout, I highlight key words on his page that I want him to
look up in his translator. He writes the translation for the words above the
English word.
- When
I give a reading handout (eg. from a textbook), I highlight the important
sentences and ask him to focus on reading those. I usually highlight 10-20%
of the text.
- My
students completed their first lab activity last week. He didn’t have a partner,
so I placed him with another student who seems friendly and understands the
material fairly well.
-Last
week my students wrote their first quiz. I adapted the quiz for Y in the
following ways: (this took me about 2-3 minutes in total)
- For
calculation questions I included a completed example for each type of
question (eg. The instruction said “convert each number into scientific
notation”, I added the completed example: 0.036 = 3.6 x 10-2. That
way he could still understand what to do even if he couldn’t understand the
written instructions.)
- For
a word problem with calculations, I underlined the known and unknown
variables in the question so they were clear.
- I
crossed off the multiple choice questions about the states of matter. He
didn’t complete them (too much reading for him).
- I
added a question where he showed understanding of the states of matter by
drawing them.
- I
added a word bank to the question about labeling phase
changes.
-Prior
to the quiz, I gave Y a specific list of exactly what would be on the
quiz.
Whole-class
strategies I use that benefit all learners (including EAL
learners).
-Speak
slowly. Pause after important information. Paraphrase important information in
simpler terms. Tell students if something you’re about to say is particularly
important so they can focus on it.
-Keep
test dates or due dates for assignments written on the board.
-Incorporate
visuals into your lesson (find them on google images, sketch a picture or
diagram, refer to actual objects).
-Give
instructions (oral and written) in clear, simple sentences.
-Review
material often and in a variety of ways.
Important registration information
There is very important information in the 2 attachments below that I
hope you will find to be useful. All advocacy teachers should print these
attachments and read them to see which information is pertinent to the EAL
students in your advocacy class. You may need to use this information as you
complete registration in the coming weeks.
The registration attachment includes information on OPC (out of province credits) and special language exam. You will need to consider these as you are counting the number of credits students have earned.
EAL-important registration information for 2013-2014
The post-secondary information attachment includes information on English language proficiency requirements for EAL students at U of M, U of W, and Red River. It also has information on academic English programs available at post-secondary institutions for students who need to improve their language level. You may want to make extra copies of this document to give to your EAL advocacy students.
EAL -post-secondary information
The registration attachment includes information on OPC (out of province credits) and special language exam. You will need to consider these as you are counting the number of credits students have earned.
EAL-important registration information for 2013-2014
The post-secondary information attachment includes information on English language proficiency requirements for EAL students at U of M, U of W, and Red River. It also has information on academic English programs available at post-secondary institutions for students who need to improve their language level. You may want to make extra copies of this document to give to your EAL advocacy students.
EAL -post-secondary information
A few reading resources
As the new semester begins, I wanted to share with you a few links that I have found to be helpful for EAL students.
1. online magazines that cover current topics over a range of subject areas at a lower readability level
http://www.timeforkids.com/
http://kids.nationalgeographic.com/kids/
http://teachingkidsnews.com/
Although these sites all are designed for 'kids' they cover topics and issues that are pertinent to adolescents as well. The articles use simpler words and sentence structure, which are easier to read for EAL students and other students who have reading difficulties.
2. tumble book cloud junior (this one is especially good for ELA teachers)
http://wpl.winnipeg.ca/library/childrens/funandgames.asp
Click on 'Tumble Book Cloud Junior'
*There is free access to this resource through the Winnipeg Public Library.
This resource offers free audio books online. The texts are read aloud and the words are highlighted as they are read. This is a good resource for students who are both visual and auditory learners. Chapters can be re-read as often as the student wishes. You can also set the text to be a larger font, increase the white space (margins and spaces between words) and the volume. The titles range from classics, graphic novels and modern fiction. There is also a small collection of non-fiction texts- many of which have been produced by the National Geographic Society. The readability level of the books in this resource ranges; the level is usually listed under the title for quick reference. There are many texts here that are at a reading level accessible to our EAL population.
* I have tried this resource with the most reluctant of readers and it was very well -received.
Report Card Writing
The new report card format may be a challenging document to navigate for a newcomer parent whose level of English proficiency is low.
To respond to this, the Manitoba Department of Education has released information packages explaining the new report card in a multitude of languages other than English. This resource has been translated into:
Amharic (the official language of Ethiopia), Arabic, Chinese, Cree, German, Korean, Ojibway, Punjabi, Russian, Somali, Spanish, Tagalog, Tigrinya (another Ethiopian language) and Vietnamese.
There are many students at GCC whose parents speak one of the above languages.
These resource packages can be found at:
http://www.edu.gov.mb.ca/k12/assess/report_cards/resources.html
If you have a student in your advocacy class or in a class that you teach whose parents do not read English well, but who speak one of the languages listed above, it may be helpful to print a copy of the Gr 9-12 resource package and include it with the report card this term. OR if you have email contact with the parent, you could certainly forward the link. If you aren't sure, feel free to ask your students if their parents are comfortable reading in English. We actually have print copies in several languages now. Please check with us if you would like a copy for your student(s).
On another note, as you begin to think of comments to write on the next set of report cards, please keep in mind that both EAL students and their parents will appreciate and benefit more from comments that are worded in simple terms.
Keep sentences short (one main idea)
Avoid the passive voice (is shown, has been demonstrated etc. )
Choose simple describing words
For example, instead of writing:
Johnny has demonstrated a thorough knowledge of the essential vocabulary pertaining to this course and a consistent effort is shown in his daily assignments.
You could write something like:
Johnny knows the key words for this course. He always does his work in class each day.
Placing one's child in a foreign school system can be a very daunting thing for the parents of EAL students. Some parents express that they feel quite intimidated by the fact that they cannot communicate effectively their concerns about their child's learning with the school staff. Any added efforts to improve communication are certainly appreciated.
Assessment adaptations
Here are some general suggestions for adapting
tests/exams. Please consider using some of these:
- Allow the use of bilingual dictionaries
- Check on students after a few minutes to make sure they know what
to do
- Give practice tests that have similar types of questions (this will
help students feel more confident and comfortable during an actual
test)
- Reduce language demands (use sentence starters, fill in the blank,
accept point form notes, etc)
- Simplify instructions and wording (avoid the passive voice and
tricky words they haven’t seen before in class, make your instructions as clear
and direct as possible)
- Reduce the number of questions required
- Reduce the length of answers required
- Allow students to answer some questions orally or through
demonstrations.
- Teach test-taking strategies in class
- Be explicit about what students need to do (eg. number of sentences
or examples required)
- Remove or explain cultural references that may cause
confusion
- Include examples of how to answer a question (eg. If there are 10
matching questions, complete the first one for students to see and they complete
the following 9)
- Remove multiple choice questions and replace with T/F or fill in
the blank
- Allow more time
- Complete activities and questions in class that are similar to the
questions students will see on a test (eg. Don’t ask students to find
similarities and differences in class, but then on a test use the words compare
and contrast. If you want students to know compare/contrast, use that vocabulary
while you are teaching so they can learn it)
- Allow students to demonstrate comprehension in alternate ways
(projects, portfolios, demonstration of a skill learned, etc)
Research Projects
Completing a research project can be a very difficult
task for all students, but particularly for EAL students. Here are
5 suggestions to help EAL students complete a research project well and
without plagiarism, whether it is a project on weather for grade 10 science,
STIs for grade 11 phys ed, or Aboriginal Peoples for grade 11 history.
1.
Explicitly
model/teach the research skills you want students to do (note-taking, organizing
info, summarizing, quoting, citing sources). Don’t assume students have learned
these skills in another class.
2.
Eliminate the need for students to use Google to find information.
Find research materials at an appropriate reading
level that you want EAL students to use and
provide them with a photocopy or printout.
Students cannot paraphrase or summarize information that they can’t
understand. If the reading level is too difficult, students are forced to
copy.
** We I
would be happy to help you find resources that would be appropriate for EAL
students, please don’t hesitate to ask! **
3.
Show an
example of what a completed project looks like.
4.
Create a
checklist of the steps that are needed to complete the project. As students
complete each part, check their work to make sure they are on the right
track.
5.
Have
students complete their written work during class time, using paper and pen. I
find that when students complete their notes and rough copy by hand they are
less likely to copy – it may still happen but it is less likely. Using a
computer makes copy/paste so easy and many students will do this if they
can.
I’ve included 2 attachments that you might choose to
use with students.
1.
Research
Note-taking and Summary Page (a 1 page handout for students to take notes, write
a summary, and complete a citation – I used this with my EAL class when we did
research about Aboriginal Peoples)
Research note-taking frame
Research note-taking frame
2.
Research
Organizer (a 1 page handout to show the overall organization for a research
paper or essay – students in my grade 12 anthropology class were required to
complete and hand this in with their research paper. It’s also a great way to
make sure students are on track before they begin
writing!)
Vocabulary Builders
Vocabulary is essential to comprehension.
How do we learn new words?
New words are learned both incidentally and directly.
Incidental vocabulary acquisition happens as students make sense of new words they hear or read, as they are used in context. Simply reading a word once or hearing it in class in passing is often not enough exposure a word to become part of a student's functioning vocabulary. This is where direct instruction comes into play. By offering students a chance to use the target words in different ways, you are allowing them opportunities to make connections in their brain with the new word and the idea that it represents.
The following is a list of a few direct vocabulary instruction activities that I have found to be successful with the second language courses I teach. None of these are complicated to set up nor require fancy supplies.
I encourage you to try out a combination of them whenever your students need to learn a series of new words.
1. Match-maker
Have students match the definitions on the left with the target vocabulary on the right.
For English definitions, I would encourage you to use www.learnersdictionary.com, This EAL-friendly online dictionary provides clear, simple definitions for most words that students will encounter in school.
2. Secret message scramble
Scrambled words reinforce spelling as well as comprehension. I sometimes combine this activity with a matching exercise (ie: unscramble the word, then match it to the correct definition). This activity is more motivating because of the 'secret message' at the end.
Try the 'double puzzle' function at Discovery School Puzzlemaker. It's free and easy to use.
http://www.discoveryeducation.com/free-puzzlemaker/?CFID=1981358&CFTOKEN=75991087)
3. Criss cross puzzle
Classic crossword puzzles can be a fun way to review new vocabulary.
Try the 'criss-cross' function at Discovery School Puzzlemaker. It's free and easy to use.
http://www.discoveryeducation.com/free-puzzlemaker/?CFID=1981358&CFTOKEN=75991087
4. Three of these things belong together.....
Offer students a series of terms. Three of the terms should have one quality in common. One of the words should be significantly different enough for students to identify that it doesn't belong- but not so obvious that it seems out of place. Ask students to pick which word doesn't belong in the series and explain why.
ex:
tradition ancestor custom ritual
Traditions, customs and rituals are all events or cultural practices that happen on a repeated basis for a specific purpose. An ancestor is a person.
5. A picture is worth a thousand words.
You could provide students with a series of images that they will label with the target vocabulary. OR students themselves can either draw images to represent the vocabulary or they can find images on the internet. Students could make flashcards for themselves with these pictures. These pictures could also be posted in the classroom as a word wall.
6. Word cycle
This is a really great higher-level thinking activity. The students are offered a graphic organizer that is a large circle. Attached to the circle are several target words, spaced evenly around the circle and numbered in a clockwise manner.
Students have to create sentences that use each set of adjacent words in context. They need to go all around the circle, making sentences that incorporate both words. * See the image below for a sample.
7. Classic Cloze
The cloze passage is a tried-and-true vocabulary builder. Having students use new words in simple, but deliberately contextualized sentences is a great way for them to show that they understand the meaning. Students could also be given actual sentences from a text they have read or video they have seen in class with key words missing.
8. Scattergories
Categorizing words reinforces word retention and application. For this activity, offer students a jumbled list of vocabulary and have them rewrite the words under different category headings, as they apply to the content of your course. This activity could be followed up with discussion in which students justify their choices of categories.
9. Word search
This is a good calming activity for reinforcement of spelling and word recognition. To make it more challenging, the standard word list could be substituted with contextual clues (like a crossword puzzle). Discovery School Puzzlemaker offers a free word search maker.
http://www.discoveryeducation.com/free-puzzlemaker/?CFID=1981358&CFTOKEN=75991087
10. Sentence scramble
Take sentences that use the target word in context. Scramble up the words and have the students put them back in order. Sometimes I like to do this activity on large pieces of paper and have students physically move the words into place instead of writing them.
ex: YOUR STRONG TO RESUME IMPRESSION FIRST A MAKE NEEDS
Your resumé needs to make a strong first impression.
11. Word weddings
Break words into parts and offer students a scrambled list of these word parts.
Have the students find the matching word parts and join them together, writing the complete words. This activity works particularly well for words that have Latin or Greek prefixes or suffixes or compound words that can be broken into parts. This activity could also be done with word parts written on large pieces of paper- each student having a part and having to find his/her match.
ex:
TUDE ATOR LATI ALTI TEC ELE GEO TUDE TONIC VATION LONGI TUDE EQU GRAPHY
geography latitude tectonic elevation altitude equator longitude
12. Definition race
This activity is wildly popular and gets the students out of their seats. Students are divided into teams and sit in rows. One member of each team stands at the whiteboard, marker in hand and ready to write. The teacher reads aloud the definition of a word. Students must then write the word they think matches the definition on the board as fast as they can. The first team with the correct word wins a point. Every team member must take their turn.
At the end, to even the score and to make it possible for even a weaker team to win, students can elect one team member to represent the team. The teacher gives a really challenging question worth multiple points.
The team with the most points wins.
13. Classic Concentration
Students play in small teams or in pairs. Target words and definitions are written on separate index cards. The cards are shuffled and placed face-down on their table. Students have to choose two cards and try to make a match (word & correct definition or picture of the word). If they don't get a match, they have to turn the cards over and the other team gets a turn. The team with the most matches at the end of the game wins.
if you have any questions about how to implement these strategies with your course content, please do not hesitate to contact me.
How do we learn new words?
New words are learned both incidentally and directly.
Incidental vocabulary acquisition happens as students make sense of new words they hear or read, as they are used in context. Simply reading a word once or hearing it in class in passing is often not enough exposure a word to become part of a student's functioning vocabulary. This is where direct instruction comes into play. By offering students a chance to use the target words in different ways, you are allowing them opportunities to make connections in their brain with the new word and the idea that it represents.
The following is a list of a few direct vocabulary instruction activities that I have found to be successful with the second language courses I teach. None of these are complicated to set up nor require fancy supplies.
I encourage you to try out a combination of them whenever your students need to learn a series of new words.
1. Match-maker
Have students match the definitions on the left with the target vocabulary on the right.
For English definitions, I would encourage you to use www.learnersdictionary.com, This EAL-friendly online dictionary provides clear, simple definitions for most words that students will encounter in school.
2. Secret message scramble
Scrambled words reinforce spelling as well as comprehension. I sometimes combine this activity with a matching exercise (ie: unscramble the word, then match it to the correct definition). This activity is more motivating because of the 'secret message' at the end.
Try the 'double puzzle' function at Discovery School Puzzlemaker. It's free and easy to use.
http://www.discoveryeducation.com/free-puzzlemaker/?CFID=1981358&CFTOKEN=75991087)
3. Criss cross puzzle
Classic crossword puzzles can be a fun way to review new vocabulary.
Try the 'criss-cross' function at Discovery School Puzzlemaker. It's free and easy to use.
http://www.discoveryeducation.com/free-puzzlemaker/?CFID=1981358&CFTOKEN=75991087
4. Three of these things belong together.....
Offer students a series of terms. Three of the terms should have one quality in common. One of the words should be significantly different enough for students to identify that it doesn't belong- but not so obvious that it seems out of place. Ask students to pick which word doesn't belong in the series and explain why.
ex:
tradition ancestor custom ritual
Traditions, customs and rituals are all events or cultural practices that happen on a repeated basis for a specific purpose. An ancestor is a person.
5. A picture is worth a thousand words.
You could provide students with a series of images that they will label with the target vocabulary. OR students themselves can either draw images to represent the vocabulary or they can find images on the internet. Students could make flashcards for themselves with these pictures. These pictures could also be posted in the classroom as a word wall.
6. Word cycle
This is a really great higher-level thinking activity. The students are offered a graphic organizer that is a large circle. Attached to the circle are several target words, spaced evenly around the circle and numbered in a clockwise manner.
Students have to create sentences that use each set of adjacent words in context. They need to go all around the circle, making sentences that incorporate both words. * See the image below for a sample.
7. Classic Cloze
The cloze passage is a tried-and-true vocabulary builder. Having students use new words in simple, but deliberately contextualized sentences is a great way for them to show that they understand the meaning. Students could also be given actual sentences from a text they have read or video they have seen in class with key words missing.
8. Scattergories
Categorizing words reinforces word retention and application. For this activity, offer students a jumbled list of vocabulary and have them rewrite the words under different category headings, as they apply to the content of your course. This activity could be followed up with discussion in which students justify their choices of categories.
9. Word search
This is a good calming activity for reinforcement of spelling and word recognition. To make it more challenging, the standard word list could be substituted with contextual clues (like a crossword puzzle). Discovery School Puzzlemaker offers a free word search maker.
http://www.discoveryeducation.com/free-puzzlemaker/?CFID=1981358&CFTOKEN=75991087
10. Sentence scramble
Take sentences that use the target word in context. Scramble up the words and have the students put them back in order. Sometimes I like to do this activity on large pieces of paper and have students physically move the words into place instead of writing them.
ex: YOUR STRONG TO RESUME IMPRESSION FIRST A MAKE NEEDS
Your resumé needs to make a strong first impression.
11. Word weddings
Break words into parts and offer students a scrambled list of these word parts.
Have the students find the matching word parts and join them together, writing the complete words. This activity works particularly well for words that have Latin or Greek prefixes or suffixes or compound words that can be broken into parts. This activity could also be done with word parts written on large pieces of paper- each student having a part and having to find his/her match.
ex:
TUDE ATOR LATI ALTI TEC ELE GEO TUDE TONIC VATION LONGI TUDE EQU GRAPHY
geography latitude tectonic elevation altitude equator longitude
12. Definition race
This activity is wildly popular and gets the students out of their seats. Students are divided into teams and sit in rows. One member of each team stands at the whiteboard, marker in hand and ready to write. The teacher reads aloud the definition of a word. Students must then write the word they think matches the definition on the board as fast as they can. The first team with the correct word wins a point. Every team member must take their turn.
At the end, to even the score and to make it possible for even a weaker team to win, students can elect one team member to represent the team. The teacher gives a really challenging question worth multiple points.
The team with the most points wins.
13. Classic Concentration
Students play in small teams or in pairs. Target words and definitions are written on separate index cards. The cards are shuffled and placed face-down on their table. Students have to choose two cards and try to make a match (word & correct definition or picture of the word). If they don't get a match, they have to turn the cards over and the other team gets a turn. The team with the most matches at the end of the game wins.
if you have any questions about how to implement these strategies with your course content, please do not hesitate to contact me.
Academic Conversations
Have you ever tried to facilitate student
conversations within your classroom and had a result like this?
Student A: “So, what do you think about
this?”
Student B: “It was OK.... What about
you?”
Student A: “I
dunno.”
It’s not exactly an example of clear, thoughtful, or
meaningful dialogue. How can teachers help students practice speaking
skills?
We attended a conference a couple of
weeks ago about how to build students’ capacities to use academic language in
the classroom, and particularly how to have clear and meaningful academic
conversations about their
learning.
Jeff Zwiers talked about how to make academic language
accessible to students and provided several specific strategies and activities
that would be useful across content areas. The strategies that he talked about
are very helpful for EAL learners, but also for all learners in your classes.
Here are two of the strategies we learned.
1.
Quote Activity (useful as a pre-reading
strategy)
-
The
teacher chooses key quotes from a text that students will read (perhaps 6-8
different quotes).
-
Copy the
different quotes onto coloured strips of paper.
-
Students
walk around and meet with students who have different quotes (ie different
coloured papers) to talk about their predictions about the text. Sample sentence
starters for students are:
“My quote is
_________”
“I predict the text will be
about ______ because _______”
“ Given the clues I have heard so far
such as ______, I think the text will be about _____”
-
As
students meet with multiple other students, they will hear many quotes and can
begin to synthesize other quotes and other students’ predictions into their own
predictions.
2.
Academic Conversation Placemat
-
This is a
piece of paper that is in front of students as they are having academic
conversations during class. Prompts and sentence starters are written on the
placemat to remind students of ways to extend and deepen their
conversations.
-
The
placemat has prompts to help students: elaborate, clarify, paraphrase,
synthesize key points, build on ideas, and support ideas with
examples.
I got this file from Jeff Zwier’s website.
http://www.jeffzwiers.com/
Check out his website- as he has much to offer in terms of strategies to get students talking!
Giving EAL students specific prompts and
sentence starters is a great way to help them develop their language skills
(both written and orally). As an example, I’ve
recently given my EAL students a compare/contrast essay assignment. I’ve
included sentence starters within each paragraph to give them clues about what
to write next. This tool has helped them organize their writing. They are
learning how to write an essay, so that at some point in the future they can
complete an assignment like this without prompts.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)